Why your journal P&L can differ from your platform
Per-side commissions, exchange and NFA fees, and swaps: the reasons two P&L figures disagree.
The short version
Two P&L figures for the same trades often disagree. The usual cause is not a wrong trade. It is that one figure is before costs and the other is after.
The main costs are commission, exchange and regulatory fees, and overnight financing (swap).
Gross and net
- Gross P&L is the price difference times size. It ignores costs.
- Net P&L is gross P&L minus all fees. This is what your account balance actually felt.
- Some platforms show gross in one screen and net in another. Check which one you are looking at.
Commission is charged per side
Futures commission is usually quoted per contract, per side. A side is one fill: the buy or the sell. A full trade in and out is a round turn, which is two sides.
Example numbers only: a fee of 1.00 per contract per side, trading 3 contracts, costs 3 × 1.00 × 2 = 6.00 for the round turn. If you compare to a report that shows only one side, you will see a gap.
Exchange, NFA and clearing fees
On top of the broker’s commission, futures trades carry fees from the exchange, the National Futures Association (NFA) and the clearing house. Some brokers quote an all-in price. Others list these separately.
If your journal uses only the broker commission, it will under-count. If it uses an all-in rate and your platform also lists exchange fees, you can count them twice. Find out which one your numbers use.
Swaps and funding
Forex and CFD brokers charge or pay a swap when you hold a position past the daily rollover. It can be a charge or a credit. Perpetual crypto contracts have a similar payment called funding.
If a journal shows only commission, or only price profit, the swap is missing. Over long holds it can be a visible part of the result.
Other reasons numbers differ
- Rounding: fees are rounded to the cent per fill, so totals can differ by small amounts.
- Trading day: a trade near the rollover can land on a different day in two tools.
- Missing fills or a different account: check that both views cover the same trades.
- Currency: amounts in different currencies cannot be added directly.
- Open trades: one tool may include a position that has not closed yet.
How to reconcile
- Pick one trade and compare gross P&L first. If gross matches, the difference is in fees.
- Compare the fee for that trade with your broker’s statement.
- Then compare totals over a short period, like one day.
How Tradeopath shows this
- P&L in the journal is net: realized P&L minus fees. A fee is shown per trade, and when a trade has a swap the fee is split into Commission and swap.
- If your broker or file states a fee, Tradeopath uses it. Otherwise the account’s fee profile prices each fill per contract, per side. In Settings → Accounts you can pick a profile, or set custom rates per instrument with commission, exchange/NFA/clearing and other fees. A sim account can be set to free.
- When you save a profile you can apply it to past trades. This re-prices only the fills Tradeopath priced itself. Fees stated by your broker or typed by you are kept.
- Some connections do not report commission. For example, TradeLocker’s public data has none, so the fee is zero unless you set a custom fee profile, and swap is not included.
- MetaTrader reports swap separately from commission, and Tradeopath keeps them apart. Perpetual funding is shown as Funding on crypto trades.
This guide is education, not financial advice. Examples use made-up numbers. Firms and platforms set their own rules and can change them, so always read your own. Trading involves risk of loss. Risk disclaimer